circustic sarcas

Diary of K. Watanabe

very beautiful but...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qgXn_SJJVHU
from the comment:

xxxxx
i don't like this version, it's not impressionistic enough for me, sorry

yyyyy
What the hell is "impressionistic"? and "impressionistic ENOUGH"?? What a pity for you that you don't h e a r ! Francois is a genius and his manner to play Ravel is authentic, is the purest french piano tradition...

zzzzz
The idea of impressionism being quantifiable is senseless.

what are they talking about? what's the matter with "impressionism"? no way. i don't care it's "impressionistic" or not. that's only how you call it, and i do not care about it. personally i do not think the word impressionism is suitable for ravel's music...